Rais Bhuiyan, immigrant from Bangladesh, Muslim Victim of Post-9/11 Hate Crime, Advocates to Spare Life of Assailant
জুলাই 20, 2011 মন্তব্য দিন
Rais Bhuiyan, Muslim Victim of Post-9/11 Hate Crime, Advocates to Spare Life of Assailant
Rais Bhuiyan, Victim of Post-9/11 Shooting Spree, Pleads To Spare Attacker Mark Stroman’s Life
Just weeks after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, a masked man stormed into the Dallas convenience store where Rais Bhuiyan, a Muslim immigrant from Bangladesh, worked as a cashier. He asked where Bhuiyan was from — then shot him in the face at point-blank range before he could reply.
His attacker was Mark Stroman, an avowed white supremacist and methamphetamine addict, who was caught and confessed to the shooting as well as two other attacks on South Asian convenience store workers. Those men died, while Bhuiyan survived, although he was blinded in one eye and still carries 35 shotgun pellets embedded in his face.
In less than 48 hours, Stroman is scheduled to die by lethal injection at the Texas death chamber at Huntsville for the crimes. A last-ditch appeal to the Supreme Court for a stay of execution was rejected without comment in June.
But even as the clock runs down on Stroman’s time on death row, an unlikely advocate is trying to spare his life: Bhuiyan, the man he casually shot and left for dead nearly a decade ago.
Over the past several months, Bhuiyan, a devout Muslim, has mounted an aggressive campaign to convince Texas authorities to commute Stroman’s sentence to life in prison without the possibility of parole. He has asked the state board of pardons and paroles to make a positive recommendation for clemency to Gov. Rick Perry, and has asked Texas prison administrators for permission to meet face-to-face with Stroman for a victim-offender reconciliation process.
After those efforts were met with no response from Texas officials, Bhuiyan filed a lawsuit against the state, arguing that his rights as a crime victim to meet with his attacker had been unjustly denied. That lawsuit was moved from state to federal court on Monday and remains unresolved.
In an interview with HuffPost, Bhuiyan said his efforts on behalf of Stroman were motivated by his Muslim faith. The Koran teaches that those who forsake retribution and forgive those who have wronged them become closer to God, he said.
“My faith teaches me that saving a life is like saving the entire human race,” he said.
Bhuiyan is not alone in his efforts to save Stroman’s life. He has support from family members of the other victims, including the widows of the two murdered men, Waqar Husan and Vasudev Patel, he said.
“We decided to forgive him and want to give him a chance to be a better person,” Nadeem Akhtar, Husan’s brother-in-law, said in an interview.
Akhtar said that his sister, Husan’s widow, had written a letter requesting that the Dallas district attorney’s office support the effort to obtain clemency for Stroman. The district attorney’s office declined to support the petition, however.
According to those close to Stroman, the efforts by Bhuiyan on his behalf have contributed to a change of heart in a man who called his crimes “patriotic” before his trial and who prosecutors once described as a cold-blooded killer.
In an interview last week, Stroman told Ilan Ziv, a documentary filmmaker, that he was remorseful for the crimes and was deeply moved by Bhuiyan’s attempts to save his life.
“I received a message that Rais loved me and that is powerful,” said Stroman, who suffered extreme abuse and neglect as a child at the hands of his alcoholic parents, according to court records.
“I want to thank him in person for his inspiring act of compassion. He has forgiven the unforgiveable and I want to tell him that I have a lot of love and respect him,” he added.
Ziv, who met with Stroman for several hours on Monday, said the condemned man had little hope that Bhuiyan’s efforts would succeed in sparing his life.
“He’s very realistic,” Ziv said. “He knows he’s got no chance.”
Stroman’s last bid for a reprieve will come in less than 48 hours, as the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles weighs his petition for clemency or a stay of execution. The board has voted for clemency just once in the last 10 years, a period when the state carried out a record 231 executions. A spokeswoman for Perry’s office said the governor has not expressed an opinion on the petition to the board.
Bhuiyan’s request to meet face-to-face with Stroman before the execution — a meeting that Stroman has enthusiastically agreed to — is also unlikely to occur. Michelle Lyons, a spokeswoman for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, said that both victims and offenders must go through months of counseling and complete other preparatory work before such a meeting can take place.
“There just is not enough time to prepare the victim and the inmate for a meeting,” Lyons said.
Bhuiyan said he would have begun the mediation process long ago, but was not informed of his rights to such a meeting by the Dallas district attorney. That complaint was the basis for his lawsuit attempting to force the state to postpone Stroman’s execution until the mediation meeting could take place; a state judge in Austin ruled Monday that the suit belonged in federal court.
If the suit is dismissed and Stroman’s bid for clemency is denied, the execution will almost certainly go ahead as scheduled at 6 p.m. Wednesday evening.
For Bhuiyan, such an outcome would be a tragedy. “If he’s given a chance, it’s very likely that he can contribute to society,” he said. “If he can educate one person who is full of hate, that is an achievement.”
Yet at least one mind has been changed by Bhuiyan’s outreach — his attacker’s.
“It is due to Rais’ message of forgiveness that I am more content now than I have ever been,” Stroman said in the interview with the documentary filmmaker. “If I don’t make it I want Rais to carry on his work teaching people not to be prejudiced.”
“We need to make sure there is not another Mark Stroman,” he concluded.
The Huntsville Item, Huntsville, TX
July 20, 2011
Texas man executed for post 9/11 slaying
HUNTSVILLE — A death row inmate’s life was spared two hours longer than expected Wednesday evening due to a delay in the court appeals process.
The surviving victim of Mark Stroman’s post-9/11 shooting spree in the Dallas-area made the unconventional gesture of requesting the courts to halt Stroman’s execution in an effort to set up mediation between the two.
Rais Bhuiyan, who was left partially blind after being shot in the face by Stroman, filed a lawsuit suggesting his Muslim faith required him to forgive his offender. Bhuiyan also said he wanted to meet with Stroman to learn more about why the shootings occurred.
A federal district judge in Austin rejected Bhuiyan’s suit and request for injunction on Wednesday afternoon, the Associated Press reported. His lawyers appealed the ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court, but Justice Antonin Scalia rejected it as well.
However, Bhuiyan’s last-minute appeal in state court Wednesday evening in Austin delayed Stroman’s execution but requests to delay any further were denied.
In a separate appeal to the Supreme Court, Stroman’s lawyer Lydia Bryant pointed to Bhuiyan’s lawsuit and argued that attorneys during Stroman’s trial and in earlier stages of his appeals were deficient for not illustrating “the path that led him to this violent frenzy.”
In October 2001, Stroman murdered what he believed to have been a Middle Eastern convenience store worker in retaliation to 9/11 terrorist attacks – in which he claimed his sister was killed. But no evidence shows Stroman’s sister ever existed, according an AP source.
Stroman claimed his attacks were out of grief, rage and patriotic duty. The victim was 49-year-old Vasudev Patel, an immigrant from India, not the Middle East. Bhuiyan and the other victim who was killed were also from parts of South Asia.
Stroman was strapped to a gurney in the death chamber at 8:29 p.m. He was pronounced dead less than 25 minutes later. Prior to his death, Stroman described himself as “at peace” with his destiny and discouraged all forms of hatred.
“Even though I lay on this gurney, seconds away from my death, I am at total peace,” he said. “May the Lord Jesus Christ be with me. Hate is going on in this world and it has to stop. Hate causes a lifetime of pain.”
Stroman’s juvenile record showed he participated in an armed robbery at age 12. He served at least two prison terms for prior convictions of burglary, robbery, theft and credit card abuse. Stroman was free on bond for gun possession at the time of the shootings.
For his final meal request, Stroman received battered chicken fried steak with gravy, 12 crispy pieces of bacon, a ham and cheese omelet, fried potatoes, squash and okra. He also received three large Dr. Pepper’s and a pint of vanilla Blue Bell Ice Cream.
Stroman spoke to his personal witnesses in the death chamber until the lethal doses took its effect on him.
“Even though I lay here, I’m still a proud American – Texas loud, Texas proud. God bless America. God bless everyone,” he added.
Stroman’s death is the eighth execution in Texas this year. Eight more executions are scheduled within the next three months in the nation’s busiest death penalty state.